The Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union

Summary of The Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union

Origins

The Articles of Confederation emerged during the American Revolutionary War as the thirteen colonies sought to establish a unified government to coordinate their fight against British rule. Drafted by the Continental Congress in 1777, the Articles aimed to create a “firm league of friendship” among the states for mutual defense, liberty, and welfare (Article III). The document reflected the colonists’ deep-seated distrust of centralized authority, a reaction to their experiences under British governance. Each state retained its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, delegating only specific powers to the central government (Article II). This structure was intended to preserve state autonomy while fostering cooperation during a time of crisis.

Process

The creation and ratification of the Articles were marked by significant delays and debates:

• Drafting (1776–1777): In June 1776, the Continental Congress appointed a committee to draft the Articles. After over a year of deliberation, primarily over representation, taxation, and western land claims, the final version was approved on November 15, 1777.
• Ratification (1777–1781): The Articles required unanimous consent from all thirteen states, a process that took nearly four years. Disputes, particularly over western territories, stalled progress. Maryland, for instance, insisted that states with large land claims cede them to the central government. Ratification was completed on March 1, 1781, after Virginia agreed to relinquish its western lands, marking the official establishment of the confederation.

Events

The Articles established a weak central government, leading to several notable events and challenges:

• Government Structure: The Confederation featured a unicameral Congress where each state had one vote (Article V). There was no executive or judicial branch, and Congress lacked the power to tax or regulate commerce directly (Article VIII). States were responsible for funding the common treasury based on land value, a system reliant on voluntary compliance.
• Key Challenges:
  • Economic Instability: Without taxation authority, Congress struggled to finance the war and postwar needs, relying on state contributions that were often insufficient.
  • Interstate Conflicts: States imposed tariffs and engaged in disputes over trade and boundaries, with Congress powerless to intervene effectively (Article IV).
  • Shays’ Rebellion (1786–1787): This uprising of debt-burdened farmers in Massachusetts exposed the government’s inability to maintain order or respond to internal threats, as Congress could not raise a national force without state approval (Article VI).
• Foreign Relations: Congress’s limited authority hindered treaty negotiations and debt repayment, weakening the nation’s international standing (Article IX).

Implications for the Formation of the Nation

The Articles’ shortcomings significantly shaped the United States’ development:

• Push for Reform: The Confederation’s inability to address economic chaos, interstate discord, and security threats like Shays’ Rebellion fueled calls for a stronger government. This dissatisfaction culminated in the Constitutional Convention of 1787, where the U.S. Constitution was drafted to replace the Articles.
• Federal Framework: The Articles’ emphasis on state sovereignty influenced the Constitution’s federal system, balancing power between states and the national government. The document’s failures highlighted the need for checks like an executive branch and taxation powers.
• Lasting Debates: The Articles set a precedent for tensions between states’ rights and federal authority, debates that persist in American governance. The transition to the Constitution marked a shift toward a more unified nation while retaining elements of state autonomy.

---

Conclusion

The Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union, ratified on March 1, 1781, was the first attempt to unite the American states under a national framework. Originating from the Revolutionary War’s demand for cooperation, it prioritized state sovereignty, resulting in a weak central government. Its prolonged drafting and ratification process reflected early divisions, while its operational failures—economic instability, interstate strife, and inadequate defense—exposed the need for reform. The Articles’ legacy lies in its role as a stepping stone to the U.S. Constitution, shaping the nation’s federal structure and enduring political discourse.

Download File